Research project sponsored by Luxembourg School of Business and MindForest

Early Warning Signals

Phase 1 was executed between June 2021 and Spring 2024. The reports were published in Fall 2024.

Cover of the White Book Be ahead, Be ready

Context

Navigating the unknown.

There is no right or wrong foresight: there is only better foresight.

In today's market, the frequency of change and the corresponding impacts on companies constantly increase. A reactive mode is no longer appropriate. However, discontinuities and strategic surprises do not emerge without warning. Early warning signals comprise part of the environmental scanning required for the elaboration of corporate strategy. However, the management of strategic surprises is still poorly addressed. The missing link lies in collecting data and noises emitted by the market or the macroscopic environment and their proper qualification as early warning signals.

To fill this gap, it is first necessary to acknowledge that there is nothing weak in the signal itself. What is weak is the attention paid to the signal when it is still possible to make decisions, and avoid reactive modes endangering the business model. The qualification of early warning signals depends on the ability to work as a theorist who operates a searchlight. The question under analysis does not deal with knowing the unknown; it deals with navigating the unknown. To take the future more seriously, it is necessary to acknowledge that there is no right or wrong foresight: there is only better foresight. Early warning signals serve the process of making the most appropriate decisions in due time.

Results

Results collected with the questionnaire and the interviews.

This research acknowledges the relevance of early warning signals (EWS) in all companies, big or small. It improves the understanding of the ways of working about the sensing and seizing phases leading to business model adaptation and proactive management of risks and disasters.

  • Every manager watches for signals

    All categories of managers, and all categories of companies, scrutinize EWS. However, they neither devote the same attention to signals, nor focus on the same categories of signals.

  • Pragmatism and active listening

    Responses to the questionnaire and interviews explain that a broad range of ways of working exist in companies to manage signals. Pragmatism prevails with respect to the identification of signals from all potential sources. Interviewees always stress the importance of active listening.

  • Interpreting is harder than collecting

    Signal interpretation is more difficult than signal collection, and less complex than the appraisal of the subsequent actions for strategic adaptation.

  • Company size shapes the process

    Ways of working for the sensing and seizing differ in SMEs, intermediate companies, and large companies. The formalism of interactions increases with the size of companies, even though oral communication remains the most effective way to transport signals in all sizes of organizations.

  • Trusted conversations between leaders

    Direct interactions between senior managers in trusted and neutral environments represent a key success factor for the appraisal of signals to feed business model adaptation.

  • The role of IT systems and AI

    Some initial conclusions are also available about the role of IT systems and AI for signal computation.

From the field

Initial results collected with the EWS research project.

The signals are there. You have to listen to them and you have to communicate about them.
Some companies either do not see the need to adapt to EWS or do not know how to take action and handle the subsequent change management.
A signal is 'weak' because of the lack of consistency between the 'event' and the observing system's cognitive map.
David W. Versailles
Paying attention to EWS and dealing with the lessons learnt from them is easier to translate inside organisations if they already cope with safety or security regulations.
Individual recognition of EWS is worthless without the ability to gain management attention.
No one saw the pandemic or the flooding coming, but some executives interviewed during the project said: "We were not per se prepared, but we could cope with it".
When dealing with EWS, the first prerequisite is the willingness to learn.

Field research

Research in Luxembourg's business community.

For this research project, we have installed a field research protocol based on semi-structured interviews, participant observation and a questionnaire, with systematic triangulation of perspectives associated with the different categories of stakeholders active in Luxembourg's business community. The project started in June 2021 among the Luxembourg business community.

Luxembourg's business ecosystem is interesting because firms have retrospective experience with the flooding that occurred in July 2021 in Luxembourg and neighboring regions in Belgium and Germany, as well as with the COVID-19 pandemic, thus leading to improved awareness for business model adaptation. Luxembourg's business community also operates with a cross-cultural workforce (3 borders region; a significant number of foreign residents; 250,000 cross-border daily commuters), thus reshaping the reference to "localism" and mandating a zoom out from personal cultural references.

Research protocol timeline from June 2021 to Q4 2022: literature review, interviews, data analysis, questionnaire and final findings
Data collection articulated two phases: semi-structured interviews (incl. participant observation) and a questionnaire operated with SurveyMonkey. Both activities were operated in the Luxembourg business community after the end of the COVID-19 pandemic. The figure (reproduced from the 2024 White Book) provides an overview of the research protocol and the three subsamples in this investigation.

Interviews

25+ interviews were conducted between September 2021 and January 2022, out of which 11 were codified and used for the elaboration of the White Book. Different categories of managers (owners, CxOs, and middle managers) were interviewed in various categories of firms (startups, SMEs, medium-sized companies, and global business units from international firms). Interviews deliberately did not focus on front-line employees. The codification of interviews was 80% completed before starting the questionnaire design. A specific webinar was organized with interviewees and practitioners from the Luxembourg business community to present interim results and collect feedback at the end of the interview phase.

Questionnaire

The questionnaire was administered through SurveyMonkey and disseminated through social media (LinkedIn) to the local business community. It included explicit questions about the respondents' locations and citizenship. Specific invitations to respond were listed in newsletters sent by the Luxembourg Chamber of Commerce and other local communities. Questionnaire responses were collected between Feb. 22nd and June 26th, 2022. Microsoft Excel and R were used for data analysis. The questionnaire was designed in English.

Research team

The people behind the project.

Principal investigator and lead researcher
David W. Versailles
Project managers
David W. Versailles, Dino Dogan and Nico Hoffeld, supported by Mrs Jane Barton
Data collection
David W. Versailles, Dino Dogan, Matteo Forgiarini, Borna Jalsenjak
Qualitative data codification
David W. Versailles, Dino Dogan, Matteo Forgiarini, Borna Jalsenjak, Ivan D. Dogan
Support to qualitative data codification
Nico Hoffeld, during validation seminars
Quantitative data management
David W. Versailles and Matteo Forgiarini
Proof editing and quality management
Jane Barton, supported by David W. Versailles
DAO and design of final deliverables
ISK Consulting SA and David W. Versailles
Pictures and artwork in the deliverables
David W. Versailles (represented by ISK Consulting SA)

Presentation events

Results shared with practitioners.

Feb. 22nd, 2022

Presentation event with practitioners interviewed during the 1st data collection phase

Program

  • Presentation of interim results available after the codification of interviews
  • Validation of interpretations and discussion of interim results

Information

david.versailles@luxsb.lu

Practitioners at the EWS presentation event Research team at the EWS presentation event

Deliverables and downloads

White Book (in English)

Be ahead, Be ready

Insights about the use of Early Warning Signals in Luxembourg's business community

by David W. Versailles, with contributions by Dino Dogan, Matteo Forgiarini, Borna Jalsenjak, Ivan Dino Dogan, Nico Hoffeld, Jane Barton

125 pages · May 2024

Publications

Academic publications and contributions to conferences.

Submissions to conferences started with the academic year 2022-2023. Presentations are posted here once validated or accepted by the conferences and journals.

Research team at the Business Model Conference

2023 · Business Model Conference, Forlì, Italy

"Be ahead, be ready. Sensing and seizing early warning signals for business model reconfiguration"

by David W. Versailles, Dino Dogan and Matteo Forgiarini